Burl Ives

as Sheriff Earl Hawkins

as Narrator (voice)

as Carruthers

as Max

as Dr. Paulis

as Narrator / Older Stuffy (voice)

as McMasters

as Phineas T. Barnum

as Father Neptune (voice)

as Sam the Snowman (voice)

as Captain Morton

as Fakrash

as Osh Popham

as Dr. Brits Jansen

as Judge Bruce Mallory Sullivan

as Dr. Hasselbacher

as Jack Bruhn

as Cottonmouth

as Harvey 'Big Daddy' Pollitt

as Rufus Hannassey

as Éphraïm Cabot

as Sam the Sheriff

as Lonesome

as Uncle Hiram Douglas

as Gus